Contributions of Animal Cognition to the Understanding of Human
Cognition
- Louis M. Herman
Department of Psychology and Kewalo Basin Marine Mammal Laboratory,
University of Hawaii)
(C) 1986 Dordect: Nijhoff
The writer has been engaged over the last ten
years in the study of the cognitive characteristics of bottlenosed
dolphins. These studies contribute to the rapidly growing field
of animal cognition. The description of the cognitive specializations,
abilities, and limitations of different animal species can add importantly
to our understanding of the functions of intellect in the natural
world of the animal and of the pressures that may select for intellect.
In turn, such study and analysis can place the theory and data on
human cognition in a broader comparative perspective. We can hope
to isolate special features of human cognition, as well as to identify
those features which have parallels or precursors among animal species.
The most recent work of the writer has focused on the ability of
dolphins to learn to understand sentences expressed within artificial
acoustic or gestural languages. The sentence is a hallmark of human
language and has been identified by some analysts of the work in
teaching languages to apes as fundamentally lacking in the strings
of signs or symbols produced by the apes. However, work with the
dolphins has emphasized the comprehension of language rather than
language production. AS comprehension approach permits the experimenter
to control the stimuli and cues available and allows for an objectivity
and quantification that is lacking in much of the work on language
production with the apes. The results of the dolphin language study,
to appear in Cognition during this year, demonstrate the understanding
of the semantic and syntactic features of sentences by the dolphins
in either the acoustic or the gestural medium. The results have
interesting implications for issues about the biological versus
experiential features of human language, and suggest that at least
some language skills may represent general cognitive structures
rather than special language acquisition devices unique to humans.
It is believed that discussion of the dolphin work, and of animal
cognition in general, can expand the scope and depth of the Advanced
study Institute on Cognition. Through the discussions, it is hoped
that general theories of cognition can be considered or developed
that can account for both human and animal cognition.
Herman, L. M. (1986). Contributions of animal
cognition to the understanding of human cognition. In S. E. Newstead,
S. H. Irvine & P. L. Dann (Eds.), Human assessment: Cognition
and motivation, 95-98. Dordecht: Nijhoff.
Back to Top
Dolphin
Programs | Whale
Programs | Education
Programs | Our Research
| Resource Guide
Copyright © 2002, The Dolphin Institute
|